skip to Main Content
Norton Health Law, is available for house calls. Please don’t hesitate to   contact us   if you have any questions!

Navigating Health Insurance Appeals: A Journey in Perseverance and Advocacy

Recently, a friend of the firm mentioned an experience he had several years back before becoming acquainted with our team where his insurance provider refused to pay for a routine colon cancer screening, even though it was a recommended test for his age, and he had received assurance from his insurer of its coverage for the $4,000 test in advance of the procedure.  He wished he had known more about the health insurance appeals process before paying the full amount out of pocket when he received the initial denial.

In the complex world of healthcare, navigating health insurance appeals can be a daunting task, especially for individuals grappling with health challenges. Consumers are rarely educated on the appeals process, the specific steps to take, and the benefit of consulting a Consumer Health Law Attorney to advocate for a patient on his or her behalf in this convoluted process. Whether you’ve been denied coverage for a procedure, treatment, or medication, understanding how to appeal a decision can make all the difference in receiving the care you need and the expense associated with it. In this blog, we’ll explore the ins and outs of health insurance appeals, empowering you to pursue a path to good health with confidence.



Health insurance appeals are the mechanism through which policyholders challenge denials of coverage, claim reductions, or other adverse decisions made by their insurance providers. Health insurance appeals are crucial for ensuring that you receive the medical care prescribed by your healthcare provider. When your insurance company denies coverage for a particular service or medication, it can have significant implications for your health and well-being. Appeals provide the means by which you are able to challenge these decisions, offering you a chance to present evidence and arguments in support of your claim.


Before delving into the appeals process, it’s essential to understand why health insurance claims are often denied. Some common reasons include:

  • Lack of medical necessity: Insurance companies may deem certain treatments or medications as not medically necessary based on their guidelines.
  • Out-of-network providers: Seeking care from providers outside your insurance network can lead to coverage denials.
  • Pre-authorization requirements: Some procedures or treatments require pre-authorization from your insurance company, and failure to obtain it can result in denial of coverage.
  • Billing errors: Incorrect coding or incomplete information on claims can lead to automatic denials.


  1. Review Your Explanation of Benefits (EOB): When you receive a denial, carefully review your EOB to understand the reason for the denial and the appeals process outlined by your insurance company. Pay attention to the critical time frame by which the insurer has outlined for you to respond to each denial.
  2. Gather Documentation: Collect any relevant medical records, prescriptions, and notes from your healthcare provider to support your appeal. Be sure to highlight any information that demonstrates the medical necessity of the treatment or medication in question.
  3. Submit an Appeal Letter: Write a clear and concise appeal letter outlining why you believe the denial was unjustified. Include any supporting documentation and reference specific sections of your insurance policy to bolster your argument.
  4. Consider External Review: If your appeal is denied at the internal level(s), you may have the option to request an external review by an independent third party. This can provide an impartial assessment of your case and potentially overturn the denial.
  5. Seek Assistance from a Consumer Health Law Attorney if Needed: The process of appealing denials from an insurer can feel overwhelming, especially when dealing with legal jargon and intricate healthcare policies. Employing the expertise of a skilled consumer health law attorney can increase your chances of overturning coverage denials and accessing the care you need.
  • Legal knowledge and Experience: Consumer health law attorneys specialize in the intersection of law and healthcare. They understand the nuances of health insurance policies, regulations, and laws governing the industry, empowering them to craft effective appeal strategies.
  • Navigating Administrative Processes: Health insurance appeals typically involve intricate administrative procedures and deadlines.  All necessary documentation must be submitted correctly and within the designated times.
  • Strategic Advocacy: Consumer health law attorneys employ strategic advocacy techniques, which include citing relevant case law, medical evidence, or regulatory provisions, to secure a favorable outcome for the policyholder.
  • Litigation Representation: Whether through administrative hearings or court proceedings, consumer health law attorneys provide robust legal representation, striving to achieve justice for their clients.

Time is clearly of the essence in the process of challenging a denial of coverage for a much-needed procedure or in a dispute a regarding the amount reimbursed for a particular treatment. When our Founding Attorney, Beth Norton, left the nursing profession over a decade ago to pursue advocacy as a Consumer Health Law Attorney, her objective was and is still today to leverage her specialized expertise in both the medical and legal industries to offer a beacon of hope for individuals and families striving for health and financial security.

MORAL OF THE STORY: Don’t be discouraged by initial denials! Perseverance and advocacy often lead to successful appeal.

Schedule a Consultation





1441 Sachem Place Suite 2
Charlottesville, VA 22901
Map & Directions [+]

Back To Top